On politics and board games, not necessarily in that order
The Political GAmer
  • Blog
  • About

The morality of soccer

6/29/2014

4 Comments

 
Syndicated columnist Ann Coulter recently published a moral analysis of the morality of a game which some, though definitely not most of the world's english speakers, call soccer. Many have spent time and effort pointing out the errors in her description of soccer, especially the farcical comparison to baseball and basketball. Some, more familiar with her previous works stopped to calling her a troll or even a performance artist, not believing that anyone could be so as ignorant as to write such a thing about soccer - it must be a prank she's playing on us. 

Coulter's analysis is not a serious one, sadly; and it seems there isn't any need for more people rebutting her claims, whether with or without calling her names. It seems to me that Coulter is not so much ignorant about soccer as she targets people who are ignorant about soccer. Only people who have never really paid any attention to a soccer game can think that there in soccer there are 'no heroes, no losers' since 'blame is dispersed'. Coulter seems bent on making sure these people, who typically identify as Americans and tend to really love sports, never even try watching soccer because it's foreign or something. That's a shame, but despite all of those responsive rants, I suspect that she is successful. In any case, she is garnering attention, which seems to be another one of her perennial goals.

Whatever the merit of her argument, despite herself Coulter points to an important direction. Most responses ignored the incredibly bombastic headline of piece, but it is, arguably, the best part of it. Coulter is not just complaining that she doesn't love soccer, but that 'any growing interest in soccer can only be a sign of the nation's moral decay'. She makes lots of twists and turns on the way to reaching that conclusion, including the offensive remark that the growth in interest in soccer is only among immigrants, but the main thrust of her argument is true: sports, and games in general, are based on rules that could and should be evaluated morally. A growing interest in a particular sport reflects a cultural shift, and that's something we can ask about: is that a good shift? Are we going in the right direction? Cultures are systems of values and the practices that we form around them; we shouldn't just accept them as they are.

If Coulter was right that soccer is a sport in which individual achievement does not play an important role, the rise of soccer would truly be a cultural and moral shift. In fact, anybody who ever coached a variety of sports with children would know that soccer sadly turns on the one player in each team that really knows how to play. In contrast, one truly great player can usually not carry his team in baseball against of a team of players who are of average skill level. On the field, it's not enough that one player can throw - somebody would have to catch. But if you're really interested in a sport that focuses on teamwork, I really recommend ultimate frisbee - no one player can do anything in frisbee, every throw has at least two ends. 

If soccer's popularity is rising in the US, I don't think it signals a great cultural shift. The biggest reason for that is that soccer is very similar to most sports that are already popular in the US. Coulter might be right that it reflects a US that's more open to outside influences and wrong to lament it, but it remains to be seen if that's really the case.

Moral and political analysis of games is the subject of this blog. Soccer is not the kind of game I intend to focus on, but Coulter's question, if not an answer, is an interesting one. Games are systems of rules that embody social values. As we play games, we practice and rehearse behaviors that are played and replayed in various social settings. What moral values are encrypted in soccer? I leave this question for the reader for the time being, with the tentative promise to revisit the subject in a future post. 
4 Comments
Maximinus
6/29/2014 02:03:01 pm

I like the interesting point that while Coulter might be nuts, there is a counter-factual universe in which she's making a point, it's just not this one.

But if adopting certain games as a society does can say something about morals, and if soccer isn't such an example, what *would* be such an example? Is there an example from history of a society adopting a game in a way that would shows a 'shift' for the worse?

Reply
TJ link
6/29/2014 08:06:09 pm

That's a really great question, and I'm not sure I'm equipped with the historical knowledge to handle it. I will say this though: let us not overplay our hand. I don't think that adopting a certain game causes a shift to the worse, these are complicated social processes that are hard to tease apart. I will say that it's likely to reflect such a shift in cultural values and that it reinforces it - as adopting widespread practices tend to create positive-feedback loops.

I would also say that soccer is a complicated game - there are different versions of soccer, and it's a flexible enough framework to reflect different cultural values. For example, the extent to which it's acceptable to argue with the ref varies and can reflect different approaches to respecting authority. Attitudes towards 'diving' and faking injuries also vary and may reflect different value structures. Analyzing a historical case study is beyond the scope of my ambition at this point, but analyzing the game and reflecting on what it might mean - that's more my game.

Reply
essay writing service reviews link
10/23/2019 10:39:03 am

The morality of soccer and analysis of the game for effective efforts on game, really perfect techniques and tips. We all are finding the more essay reviews and it is helping us to know more writing info.

Reply
webstagram link
4/17/2020 12:33:54 am

very interesting post.this is my first time visit here.i found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion..thanks for the post!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    The Political Gamer

    A student of politics and games, trying to think about play and play with some thoughts.
    What's political analysis of games?

    What's a political game?

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Tweets by @TPoliticalGAmer

    Categories

    All
    A Game Of Thrones
    Analysis
    Bluffing
    Coulter
    Coup
    Debate
    Diplomacy
    Discussion
    Faidutti
    Ludology
    Mechanics
    Politics
    Scotland
    Soccer
    Spotlight
    Strategy
    Table Talk
    Theme
    Village
    Worker Placement

    Archives

    April 2017
    November 2016
    August 2016
    April 2016
    January 2016
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014

    Introduction to board games (by SU&SD)

    Good GAming resources:
    Shut up and Sit Down
    Ludology
    The Dice Tower
    Plaid Hat GAmes
    Board With Life
    Watch it Played
    Rahdo Runs Through
    Board GAme Links
    Across the Board Games
    Keith Burgun's game design blog 

    Feminist Frequency

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly