On politics and board games, not necessarily in that order
The Political GAmer
  • Blog
  • About

Your Gaming Collection as a Window to Your Soul

2/10/2015

35 Comments

 
Today we diverge from our usual focus to participate in the The Knights' Forum, a monthly discussion that takes place in the Village Square, over where they slay the dragons on a daily basis. I have never been knighted, yet they call me the perpetual squire. If there's something my very many years as squire prepared me for is discussion, Let's just say that battles are not my forte.

Interestingly, people who like board games tend to define themselves as gamers, though many of them, yours truly included, are much better described as collectors. I can remember the moment I transformed from a gamer to a collector. Or to be more precise, the cocooning period where I huddled around myself like a little zergling morphing into a rolling baneling. And it's not that you really stop being a gamer - I still love playing games, and that's the driving force behind it all. Once you start collecting games, your attitude towards them changes. The way you look at them, the way you research them and even the way you play them - everything changes. You are not only thinking to yourself 'is this fun' or 'what is my next move' but suddenly there is this whole other question - do I need this game in my collection? Do I need it? Oh my, I really need it!
Picture
My friends and I were gaming/cocooning the other day. It was... green
Andrew of iSlaytheDragon suggested we think about games in our collections in terms of their potential. I think that's generally a good idea. As a gamer, you like certain games and perhaps certain game styles. When you start collecting games, the reasonable to do is collect games that you will either play a lot or have a blast playing them when you do. If you have limited space, you might want to bring in cubic volume into the equation but otherwise, I would say that you can value each game in terms of the fun you have playing it times the frequency you will play it. I own a spectacular fan designed copy of Dune, which is a game I rarely play. But when I do, it's a superbly unique experience (some people own Twilight Imperium III for the same reason) . On the other hand, I have Splendor, which I enjoy but isn't half as epic as Dune. But Splendor sees more play and can be played with two players on a weeknight in half an hour. So these two games might end up having the same 'value' when I consider adding them to my collection. In sum,  you can think of a game's potential, or value (v), as the number of times you play it a month (p) times the subjective grade you give the for the experience of playing it.1 

This is a fine way to think about game potential, but it's not how I manage my collection. Partly, that is because I think that what I care about is not just a game's potential, but also how it fits in my collection. When you become a collector - be it games or anything else - you don't just care about each individual item in your collection, though of course you do. Instead, you care about the collection as a whole: you want the collection to have some overall qualities and each item starts to matter partly because of the way it is reflecting on the collection as a whole. If you ever had the though 'I can't have that kind of game in my collection' than you know what I'm talking about. Your collection starts defining you as a gamer - you are the person who owns these games, nay, you are the person who curated these games. The volume and character of your collection is a reflection of your ideal as a gamer, it is your identity as a gamer. It is who you are in the gaming world - a Stephen Feld fan, a Euro-gamer or a political gamer. You are your collection. 
Picture
A taste of my collection... Or perhaps, of my gamer soul
And that's why, I think, one of the things boardgamers do when they coalesce at a virtual place like facebook, is introduce themselves by showing pictures of their collection. And it's interesting, though I won't pursue it further here, that they often share pictures of their actual shelves rather than an image such as the one I shared above. I guess there's something beautiful in the art on the boxes arranged on the shelves, or we just like to show off a piece of our life. In any case, it's striking that what we share is a picture of the collection as a whole as a way to introduce ourselves - this is who I am, this is my collection.

So what kind of considerations do we have when we think about our collection as a whole? First, there is the quality threshold. I want all my games to be good games, even pretty great games. I don't want anything in my collection that I don't really appreciate as a gamer. It really hurts my eyes to see that copy of Set in the middle between Sheriff of Nottingham and Quantum (why do I even include it? Well, I can't like about what I have... it's who I am!). I mean, Set is a fun little game - I had some good times with it. I never bought it or anything, we just got it as a gift. Still, it doesn't fit with my collection. It really lowers the bar of what should be admitted to a collection such as mine.

Second, we want our collection to reflect our tastes in gaming. As a political gamer, I couldn't pass on Tammany Hall, Warrior Knights, Diplomacy and even Dead of Winter. These games are just to important for that kind of genre to not have them included. To each his own, of course - the Uwe Rosenberg farming fan will have different 'must haves' than I do, perhaps aside from the value/potential as defined above. 

Lastly, we might care about other things that have to do with our role in our gaming group or environment. I might be a gaming missionary, wanting to introduce and convert non-gamers to my creed, so I'll want to have many light gateway games that with different themes. Or, I may be a gaming connoisseur with a regular gaming group and so I'd be stacking myself with only the most exquisite and rare deluxe editions and rare out of print games that nobody else has. Or I may be the only one buying games in my gaming group, so I'll want to have a diverse well rounded collection - with a bit of everything. If you ever thought something like "I really need a non-real-time non-space-themed cooperative game in my collection" then you probably have this kind of consideration in mind.

So... What goes through you mind when you think of your collection? Any considerations I missed?


1 I clearly haven't though this system through, but one thing that seems clear is that if we want to multiply the numbers, we would have to standardize the values. As it is now, the number of plays a game gets a month (at least in my collection) ranges from probably 1/12 to 4 or 5, which is very different from a 1 to 10 scale of subjective appreciation. You could translate frequency into a 1 to 10 scale, which  would probably make this thing a bit more useful. 
35 Comments
Situs Judi Online link
4/10/2018 02:04:14 pm

It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.

Reply
agen sbobet link
11/12/2018 03:36:03 am

If you’d like to add to that total but can’t afford to drop $500+ on a game-worn jersey, there are several other ways you can help. You can donate to the Ventura County Community Foundation here. You can learn more about the Red Cross, long a trusted resource for rebuilding families along a wide spectrum of disasters, and its efforts to help victims to wildfires here. And if you’d like to help the Los Angeles Fire Department directly, you can learn more below.

Reply
Agen Judi Bola link
11/12/2018 05:02:48 am

Thanks Brooo realy realy thanks !

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/12/2018 05:08:20 am

very giving insight I like

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/12/2018 05:12:52 am

gracias por el articulo !! ~

Reply
Agen Sbobet 2 link
11/12/2018 05:14:40 am

thanks for this info, very help me ..

Reply
Agen Sbobet 3 link
11/12/2018 05:15:00 am

Heel erg bedankt

Reply
Agen Sbobet 4 link
11/12/2018 05:15:22 am

ども ども ありがと ~

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/12/2018 05:17:51 am

very good and gives many valuable lessons

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/15/2018 02:00:55 am

thank you very much for the help

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/15/2018 02:06:31 am

Thank you for the info which is very useful for every time

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/15/2018 10:42:26 pm

Salamat sa impormasyon na kapaki-pakinabang para sa bawat oras

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/15/2018 10:42:56 pm

Благодарим Ви за информацията, която е много полезна за всеки път

Reply
Situs Judi Bola Terpercaya link
11/22/2018 03:20:35 am

a little over a yr after The Blair Witch assignment hit theaters and in consequence became a box workplace phenomenon, Artisan entertainment launched a sequel that did…the contrary.

booklet of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 changed into meant to capitalize on the success of the first movie, expanding the mythology for Blair-obsessed audiences looking forward to a different go back and forth to the Burkittsville woods. but Joe Berlinger’s self-aware sequel failed to steal fanatics the same manner its predecessor had. And that’s a disgrace as a result of booklet of Shadows is without doubt one of the most enjoyable and moneymaking sequels in horror history.

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/22/2018 04:51:44 am


very attractive and enough to provide lessons https://football69.page.tl/

Reply
Agen Sbobet link
11/23/2018 01:56:57 am

Josh Collins had on no account been to ny before ultimate summer time. His first shuttle to the metropolis, on his 22nd birthday, became for a job interview at a software enterprise.

Reply
buat akun togel link
1/14/2019 04:55:15 am

Cara membuat akun togel yang cepat dan benar di situs judi togel online yang terpercaya SukaBet.

Reply
Cara Menang Togel link
1/15/2019 11:19:50 pm

Bandar Judi Togel Online Terbaik dan Terpercaya

Reply
Agen Sbobet Terpercaya link
2/1/2019 07:32:04 am

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know

Reply
Poker Online link
7/9/2019 04:34:39 am

Kami adalah situs Poker Online http://hdfilmgezegeni.net/ yang selalu membantu semua pemain untuk menciptakan dan mengabulkan hoki disetiap permainan poker online. Jika Anda tertarik dan ingin bukti silahkan masuk dan bermain bersama kami

Reply
cara meramal togel link
7/11/2019 12:51:46 am

Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
http://creativespiritcenter.org/cara-meramal-togel-terjitu-pada-pasaran-singapore/

Reply
Poker Online link
7/16/2019 04:27:15 am

Situs Poker tempat terbaik para pecinta poker untuk menghabiskan waktu dan menghasilkan Uang yang banyak dengan cepat, Situs yang sudah resmi di Indonesia dengan status Lisensi Judi yang Valid dan Sah

Reply
Situs Judi Bola Sbobet link
8/12/2019 03:26:07 am

Dengan minimal deposit termurah yaitu Rp 25,000 yang akan diproses dengan cepat ke saldo di akun judi Anda. Karena DewaAsia sebagai Situs Judi Bola Sbobet yang sudah berpengalaman memberikan pilihan permainan game judi online dengan uang asli rupiah.
DewaAsia ini menyediakan permainan judi seperti Judi bola Sportsbook, Live Casino Online, Poker Online, slot Online dan Permainan judi online lainya.
Kami memberikan kemudahan Anda dalam melakukan pendaftaran akun judi dengan mengisi form yang sangat singkat dalam waktu 3 menit saja.

Reply
agen judi bola online link
8/15/2019 06:59:32 am

I got this web site from my pal who informed me concerning
this site and now this time I am visiting this site and reading
very informative content here.

Reply
cara mendaftar judi togel lewat online link
8/28/2019 03:32:15 am

Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
<a href="http://istanaimpian2.co/cara-mendaftar-judi-togel-lewat-online-tanpa-biaya/">cara mendaftar judi togel lewat online</a>

Reply
cara menghitung togel link
8/28/2019 03:45:52 am

Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
<a href="http://139.99.28.138/cara-menghitung-togel-dengan-rumus-sederhana-paling-akurat/">cara menghitung togel</a>

Reply
TULISTOTO OFFICIAL link
8/30/2019 09:25:03 pm

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything

Reply
TulisQQ link
9/1/2019 12:58:50 pm

I am very grateful for this article, I recommend you all to read this article. And visit my site too <a href="http://202.95.10.49">Agen BandarQ Terpercaya</a> Thanks bruhh.

Reply
btzoa idnpoker link
10/2/2019 12:25:42 am

Interesting information about your relationships can be seen in the link that will be shared for you all here Come on Join !

https://id.quora.com/profile/AG-Pokecu-Suep
https://www.linkedin.com/in/btzoa-idnpoker-btzoa-a65710194/detail/contact-info/
https://www.ranker.com/profile-of/btzoa177
https://www.theverge.com/users/btzoa177
https://www.vocabulary.com/profiles/B1TQDJVBUC9GPZ

Reply
Pasang Bola link
10/6/2019 11:53:13 pm

cara pasang bola yang mudah dan aman hanya di pokercuan yang memberikan bonus new member dan bonus setiap deposit

Reply
situs togel terpercaya 2019 link
10/13/2019 11:56:33 pm

Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
<a href="http://wlatoto88.com/situs-togel-terpercaya-2019-yang-terbaik-dengan-banyak-kelebihan/">situs togel terpercaya 2019</a>

Reply
cara mendaftar judi togel lewat online link
10/14/2019 12:08:48 am

Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
<a href="http://probet4dd.com/cara-mendaftar-judi-togel-lewat-online-via-hp/">cara mendaftar judi togel lewat online</a>

Reply
gaple uang asli link
10/21/2019 02:36:03 am

pokercuan adalah situs judi idn poker online yang menyediakan permainan capsa susun, gaple online dan juga domino qq. Minimal deposit hanya 10rb saja

Reply
poker deposit 10rb link
10/24/2019 01:03:28 am

aseanplus3 adalah situs agen judi poker dengan minimal deposit 10rb dan bagi anda yang baru bergabung dan deposit akan mendapatkan bonus new member sampai 50%

Reply
Unsur Toto Indo link
10/26/2019 04:21:13 am

Bermain di situs resmi togel terpercaya akan mendapatkan banyak keuntungan dalam jangka panjang, dengan modal yang sangat minim akan dilipatgandakan hingga 1000x lipat dari modal yang ditaruhkan. Silahkan join di situs togel resmi kami

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    The Political Gamer

    A student of politics and games, trying to think about play and play with some thoughts.
    What's political analysis of games?

    What's a political game?

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Tweets by @TPoliticalGAmer

    Categories

    All
    A Game Of Thrones
    Analysis
    Bluffing
    Coulter
    Coup
    Debate
    Diplomacy
    Discussion
    Faidutti
    Ludology
    Mechanics
    Politics
    Scotland
    Soccer
    Spotlight
    Strategy
    Table Talk
    Theme
    Village
    Worker Placement

    Archives

    April 2017
    November 2016
    August 2016
    April 2016
    January 2016
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014

    Introduction to board games (by SU&SD)

    Good GAming resources:
    Shut up and Sit Down
    Ludology
    The Dice Tower
    Plaid Hat GAmes
    Board With Life
    Watch it Played
    Rahdo Runs Through
    Board GAme Links
    Across the Board Games
    Keith Burgun's game design blog 

    Feminist Frequency

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly